untitled
These reviews represent my point of view only, and they do belong to me. Ask if you want to use them for something. The books themselves I have no ownership over.

Rating system for reviews and guides:

Everything gets ranked 1-5 stars, 1 being the worst, 5 being the best. I can get real specific sometimes, so see below for more details.

5 stars- I love it. it has that fantastic quality that makes me forget its a book and think its real life. I buy copies for friends, loan the book out, buy a new copy when it doesn't come back. If the book did something special for me, like made me cry or laugh out loud, it can get a five star rating without having "it."

4.5 stars- I like it a lot, but it doesn't have "it".

4 stars- I like it, its solid, but nothing really special.

3.5 stars- I can't decide if I like it or not.


3 stars- Its all right, it may have bored me, but i finished it.

2 stars- I either didn't understand it, or kind of hated it, but I have no gripes about it (meaning: I don't want to write insulting things about it.)

1 star-Its inacurrate about something I really know about, or its offensive, and boring, and I hated it. I probably think it shouldn't have been published.

To get zero star from me ...um...wow..that would take a lot. Like, the author would have to murder my family.

Same deal as before, for space reasons all books starting H-S are on this page.

 Historical Fiction
H

Helen of Troy by Margaret George

"Helen of Troy" is the latest offering of the amazing historical novelist Margaret George. She writes very long books encompassing the whole life of a real person, bumps and all. Her work on Henry VIII is the ultimate for Tudor fans, her novel on Cleopatra was beyond compare and now we have this-a very good book, but not her best work.

Unlike her past novels "Helen of Troy" feels more like a story and less like a total life history of the narrator. Not that this is bad, but even though some scenes are included this book has very little of Helen's early life or later life, focusing mainly on the war of Troy. Some of the mythological info on Helen's early life, such as her abduction by Theseus, is even left out of this novel, which acts to give it a more normal feel and make Helen an unusual, but not extraordinary woman of her time. Thus it is more of a story novel, and a bit unlike her past works.

When I read earlier this year "The Memoirs of Helen of Troy" by Amanda Elyot I said that Helen was a poor choice of narrator for her own life story. Ms. George proved me wrong in this. While Ms. Elyot's Helen was conceited and selfish, Helen in Ms. George's book is a normal woman of the time-and for all that she's beautiful, she may not be the most beautiful woman in the world. There is even doubt in this novel as to Zeus being her real father. Thus as a narrator, Helen does a great job of bringing the tragedy and beauty of Troy to life. She's a real person that it's pretty easy to identify with.

I also liked how Ms. George handled the Greek gods in this book. They were real, but elusive, changeable and not understandable by humans. They could be terribly mean and see it as kindness and acting to placate them was a large part of daily life. Ms. George strikes a good balance between fantasy and religion in her handling of them.

I would give this book a solid four stars. Not five because unlike her earlier works (such as her novel on Cleopatra) this novel is not mesmerizing-it does not such your attention in and hold in it place. Still though, it is a good novel and by far the best retelling of the Troy story I have read.

The Heart of The Fire by Cerridwen Fallingstar

Were I not a pagan myself there is a possibility I would think the author of this novel was insane. It claims to be a mostly-past life recall part novel sketch of the authors past life as a victim of the witch hunts in late 16th century Scotland (and that's not a spoiler, read the authors note.) If you don't believe in past lives, magic or goddess worship you may want to skip this review, and probably this book. Otherwise, read on.

Having had one past life recall myself I would say that this isn't an irrational premise to base a book on, but I seriously doubt that anyone could remember so much and as detailed an account of a life lived almost 500 years ago, even with hypnotherapy and/or drugs. That said, I do believe it is possible that the author remembered some things and wrote a novel to fill in the very large gaps she couldn't remember.

And so we have this: Fiona is a young, beautiful woman living in Scotland. Her coven is open about its practices. She, her best friend and mother are sexually promiscuous while unmarried in catholic Scotland. As is predictable, she eventually becomes a victim of a witch hunt because of the very harsh laws King James of Scotland (and later England) implemented about witchcraft.

Now, up until recently there was a belief, held in the pagan world to be fact, that several million witches were burned during the time of persecution. A belief was also held that goddess worship religion existed in pockets in most Christian countries as a remnant from before the church. Both of these have been disproved. The number of witches burned in unknown, but much lower then the number of Catholics, Protestants and Jews burned. And the goddess religion, what we know as paganism, mostly did die out except for celebrations of the sabbats which lost their meaning, and a general knowledge of herbs. Thus the historical content of this book is minimal, but is technically I suppose, still historical fiction.

And so the religion Fiona practices, and how the religion is practiced in her world is historically impossible. It is very possible that the women in her village worshiped Mary as the mother of god in the goddess form, and knew much about herbs, and practiced certain skills and arts which today are attributed to pagan roots. That said, it is still quite moving and inspiring about the goddess religion, particularly to me as a follower of it. But what is in this book is just not possible. As one example, her whole coven would have burned or killed years before if they practiced that openly in that time, and her unmarried status (and several others in her village) with being sexually active would have been more frowned upon by the village-it would have been an actual crime.

Aside from that I liked this book. It's entertaining, pretty well written and has some great love scenes (not just sex scenes, although there are a lot of those too.) One thing I really didn't like was the way the author portrays magic and witchcraft. So many people become Wiccans because of the whole magic thing, and in this book the magical actions of Fiona and others read like a fantasy novel. There is a way to write about REAL magic and real pagan rituals that don't have out and out lies or fabrications. No one is ever going to conjure a ball of light, you cannot turn anyone into a frog. But there is real magic, that anyone can work, that can be written about. The way it is in this book feels like its all for show and as a Wiccan, priestess and worker of magic it's a little offensive and very much untrue and it trivializes real magic to embellish it in writing like that.

Anyway, long story short: this is almost completely fiction, with very little actual fact, is probably not a very complete past life memory and not accurate at all about magic. But it is fun to read, so three point five stars.

The Horse Goddess by Morgan Llywelyn

I am extremely unfamiliar with Celtic mythology, which is a little odd considering that half of my genetic makeup is Celtic. So with this book I'm not sure if the story is a reinterpretation of the legend of Epona or if the author just wrote about what she thought Epona's life was like. I'm guessing it's the latter, just because while magic and fantasy elements play a part in this book Epona never does anything that would grant her goddess status. At the same time you can easily see how through oral history Epona's story could have evolved until she was held as a goddess.

This is, aside from being about Epona, a novel of the revolution of the horse. Before horses were domesticated as riding animals there was extremely limited mobility on behalf of people. There were cart horses, but they couldn't go as far or as fast or be useful in war. Riding horses really changed the world because it ment that ordinary people could travel more than five miles from their birth place with some ease.

And Epona brought, through the man she loved, riding horses to the Celtic people. 

This book isn't perfect, it has problems. Most of the dialog is annoyingly stilted and Epona undergoes this massive transformation from scared young-ish girl (say 13) to sexually active totally competent confident woman in a really short period of time-like five pages. I know this is a coming of age novel (sort of) but come on-that's just too fast.

I learned a lot reading this book. I always thought that "Celtic" referred only to people in Wales, England, Scotland and Ireland but really the Celts stretched from the black sea to Ireland. So most of European history was heavily influenced by the Celts. As historical fiction goes this book has immense value. As fantasy-well, this is not really as fantasy novel. There are small amounts of magic but really it's a misclassification on the publisher's part.

Four stars.


I


The Illuminator Brenda Rickman Vantrease

Almost all the reviews I read for this book have been 90% summary, 10% review. Admittedly, these are useful. But there are too many of them, so this will contain no summary.

The Illuminator is an ok book. Actually it's a little bit more than ok. But it has its problems. Mostly for me these problems had to do with the two romances in the book. The early stages of the romances were never really explained, at one point people were friends, the next page they were lovers. I think this all could be resolved if we could have seen the early parts of the sex scenes which were not included in the book. I don't mean a real gratuitous sex scene, just maybe, ten minutes past the first kiss. It would have the romances way more real.

For those that haven't read this book, be warned, it's not particularly upbeat. It has some wonderful uplifting moments, but most of this book is pretty depressing. But then of course, life around this time period was pretty depressing.

Other than that, the book is good. But there's nothing really special about it. It doesn't have that quality some books do-the unexplained quality that makes you love them and treasure them forever. This is a good, but ordinary book. 3.5 stars.

For more reading on this time period, try Katherine by Anya Seton.

In Lucia's Eyes by Arthur Japin

I really hate to not finish a book, no matter how much I dislike the book in question. But this novel, which seemed so promising according to the other reviews, was just not readable.

I liked the premise, Casanova's only lost love turns out to have run away in shame after being disfigured by smallpox, and later they meet and engage in a battle of the genders when she is a prostitute in Amsterdam.

But this book does not read like historical fiction. Possibly it is the translation from Dutch into English which rendered this into a snooty sudo intellectual novel on the nature of suffering. Maybe it is the translation which made all of the words in this book into things rarely seen in dictionaries. I mean, normal English isn't exactly a bad language for describing things. Sometimes a kiss is just a kiss, a smile is just a smile....not "any mouth game we could make of it" or something weird like that.

Anyway, the language of this book killed me. I lost interest by page 100, and I quite without finishing.

Two stars.

Inventing Memory by Anne Harris

I stayed up all night to finish this book.

This book starts off in ancient Samaria, where a slave named Shula who meets the goddess Inanna and becomes one of her priestess. But then she meets the goddess Belili and the snake of knowledge and finds her approach to the world much less demanding and selfish. But just when the story gets going we are sent to the present day, to meet a girl named Wendy.

Wendy has rough experiences in middle school, the boys teasing the girls making fun of her, and then she discovering the goddess and learns not to care what people think of her. She also meets Ray, a young artist who loves Wendy's view of the world and their relationship takes off. But Ray had an abusive father and soon his after school job gets a little rough, causing problems for him and Wendy.

But was does this have to do with ancient Sumer and rival goddess worship cults? The two parts of the book are apparently unconnected, except by Wendy's link to the goddess Belili, who she studies in college and has long felt connected to. Maybe Wendy is a reincarnation of Shula, the slave we meet in the beginning of the book. Maybe it's more than that. Maybe, it's something else entirely.

I won't tell you. The ending of this book blew me away.

Just read it, you'll enjoy it if you're a Wiccan, a historical fiction freak, or a person who loves suspense.

And the title will make sense once you finish the book. I promise.

Five stars easily.


J


K


Kathryn in the Court of Six Queens by Anne Merton Abbey

Katherine in the court of six queens is a historical romance novel about a fictional lady in waiting to all of Henry VIII's six queens. However, it is much more historical than romance.

Katherine herself is a Howard on her mother's side, and the cousin of Anne Boleyn. On her father's side she's the bastard granddaughter of Edward IV-this makes her royal enough that her marriage has to be ordered by the king. Since she's at court her whole life this means Henry knows everything about her love life.

Unfortunately she falls in love with a man she can never marry, the terribly dressed man of dubious parentage, John de Gael, who happens to own the only independent duchy in England. For some reason, Henry hates him. Of course, he will be Katherine's life long love.

This is not only pretty accurate stuff about the reign of Henry VIII (despite a few interjected made up characters) it's a dam fine romance about two people who grow old together, and do stop loving each other before they truly come together again. This is my favorite romance novel of all time, and the only book I'm not mad at for making Henry appear like a buffoon. Generally I like to see him as more dignified, but his personality in this book works-it's not ridiculously stupid or overbearing.

Five stars, because every now and then you just need to read a good romance novel.

 


L


Labyrinth by Kate Mosse

In the midst of "Da Vinci Code" inspired mania, this book was born. In Europe, where I first saw it, it was hailed as a "Da Vinci Code" for women. In reality this book is just a badly written suspense novel (just like the "Da Vinci Code") riding to fame because it deals with the Holy Grail. In the middle ages this cup-or whatever it was-was thought to be in possession of the Cathers in southern France. Yes, this is the same religion that largely held Jesus never died for their sins. In this novel, they appear to have found the grail, not been given it by Mary Magdalene like in the history of the Cathers, and thus started a centuries long war between powerful fringe religions.

It's been a while since I read this book, so I am fuzzy on some of the details. What I do remember is A) being a little upset at the way the author portrayed the religious sect of the Cathers, and B) just not being impressed by this book. There are too many details and at the same time to few. Surrounding details are abundant yet the suspense is so elusive that there almost is none at all. Most of the "plot twists" in this book are quite obvious to the reader and the ending could have come strait out of a soap opera. In her chosen venue the author had so much to work with around the Grail legends, but she didn't really take advantage of it.

All in all, skip this book and read "Daughters of the Grail" by Elizabeth Chadwick instead. It's a way better holy grail story. And be aware-Dan Brown did not by any means make the first written connection between Mary Magdalene and the holy grail. It is a very common historical theme.

The Lady and The Unicorn by Tracy Chevalier

I just read The Lady and The Unicorn for the second time, and was so enchanted I had to review it.

Readers of the Girl with a pearl earring will be delighted, the book is much in the same vein, but with multiple points of view instead of just one (still all in first person of course.) It's about the creation of the famous lady and the unicorn tapestries, which to be honest, I never heard of before reading this book.

I finally tacked down what I like so much about Tracy Chevalier while reading this book. And that is this: everything she writes about is ordinary. None of her characters are star crossed lovers (though they may be in love) or great heroines. They are real ordinary people who are truly living in the time period she placed them (The weaver even thought he had never seen a unicorn, but then they lived in the east with elephants!) Because of this her books are immensely comforting to read...like, reading about old friends.

A lot of people give this book bad reviews because of the romantic aspects. I think everyone who is critical of this book should read it and not judge it, once through. If you still don't like it then you can complain. But really, I love it, and think others will too. It's a simply written little masterpiece.

My only complaint is that in the tapestries pictures in the middle of the book the whole of each tapestry isn't shown-you can only see the ladies and the unicorn, which I suppose is appropriate.
Five stars.

Lady of Hay by Barbara Erskine

It seems that the reviews for this book are all over the map. This is totally understandable to me, as I just finished the book and spent a while sorting my feelings about it out.

That said, I really like this book. I'll tell you why in a moment.

Jo Clifford is nineteen years old and volunteers to be a patient in a hypnosis experiment taking place at her college. While under hypnosis Jo becomes extremely agitated and then, her hands begin to bleed. The professor conducting the experiment is thrilled, he thinks Joanna is showing signs of stigmata, but his assistant Sam Franklyn, is scared. Then, Jo's hearts stops and she nearly dies. Sam manages to bring her back to life. This is the prolog.

Fast forward fifteen years. Jo has recently broken up with Nick, who is Sam's younger brother. She is a freelance journalist and is starting to write a series on nostalgia, one of the articles is about past lives and reincarnation. At this point she has no idea what happened to her all those years in the college experiment because the doctor conducting it gave her a post hypnotic suggestion so she wouldn't remember.

Nick does know, and try's to dissuade her from writing the article, but she is too mad at him for cheating on her to care. So she begins to write the article, and is hypnotized by a doctor she goes to interview.

Immediately Jo is flung back into the past. She is Matilda de Braose, women who is married to a twelve century marcher lord in Wales, but is love with the handsome Richard de Clare. And King (currently Prince) John of Robin Hood fame is in love with her.

As Jo continues her trips to the past via regression it becomes obvious that the three men in Matilda's life, her husband William, her lover Richard and her lord John are all involved in Jo's life as well. The men, Sam, Nick and Tim (a photographer Jo frequently works with) begin to act strangely.

This book was very exciting. The story line is going at a break neck speed until about page four hundred, when it slows down it bit. It does seem like some of it could be cut, but I couldn't tell you what parts.

My only gripes with this book are few. The scenes in the past can be a little boring, the evil man in Jo's life seemed to becomes very evil very fast, and I don't think you can really hypnotize someone over the phone. Also I was a little confused about the scenes where Jo thought she was Matilda talking to her husband but really she was being hypnotized, and something like the conversation she was having never really took place in Matilda's life. (You'll understand that if you read the book.)

Spolier alert!!

Also given everything that happened in the book the ending was a little un realistic. I mean, after having a man rape you in not one but two incarnations it seems like you'd have trouble trusting him again, much less loving him. But the destiny aspect of the book sort of makes it all seem ok (not that its ever acceptable to rape someone, it just sort of explains it) and hey, its fiction.

I give this book a very solid four point five stars and I would definitely try something else by this author.

Lady Jane by Unknown Author

There is a reason no one really reads movie tie in books-and this book is a classic example of why. I ever saw the movie Lady Jane of which the book based but I knew about Jane as the Nine Day queen and thought this book would be a novel of that. Instead it appears to be a word for word retelling of the movie which no visual element at all. I mean, Jane and her husband became lovers in one spot, but the only clue I had to that happening was that the next morning they were talking about how they didn't hate each other. There wasn't even a break in the paragraph from talking at night to talking in the morning! Where was the sex? Also Guilford (the husband) goes from being an ass to a wonderful person in about five minutes!

I can't recommend this-its lacking too much.

One star

Lady of the Reeds by Pauline Gedge

This is the story of Thu, an improbably blue eyed Egyptian girl from the little town Aswat. I say improbable because the genetic trait for blue eyes is recessive, not dominate and therefore if Thu had one parent with brown eyes (which is dominate, and the case in the book) and one with blue, her eyes would still be brown. I am told that if three of her grandparents had blue eyes Thu could have blue eyes, but considering that her two grand parents on her mother's side were African, well, the odds aren't good. But that's a stupid complainant. Anyway, Thu has blue eyes, and because of them her life takes some strange turns.

Thu always wanted out of Aswat, and so when she was 14 and a seer came to consult the local god of war she swam out to his barge and offered her virginity if he would see into her future. The seer, Hui, who is an albino, refuses the offer of sex, by impressed by Thu's reading and writing ability, which her brother taught her, he takes her with her back home to be trained as a concubine for the Pharos harem. You see, Hui has a plan for the future of Egypt.

I actually thought this book was better written than the last Pauline Gedge book I read, the Eagle and the Raven, even though that book was more exciting. Gedge is really great at putting you inside Thu's headspace, and the terrible things she does for ambition seem reasonable. You feel her desperation to leave the sandy waste of a town where she was born, her true love of the Nile, her deep awe of her brother and Hui and her total humiliation and rage when she has her first sexual encounter with the Pharos.

So I give this book five stars, and I will be reading its sequel, House of Illusions.

Legacy by Susan Kay

This is without a doubt the premier novel about Queen Elizabeth the first I have ever read and it is a shame that it is out of print. No author I believe, has come close to Ms. Kay at presenting Elizabeth and those who were around her as true people with all of the jealousy's, faults and joys that really were in their lives. And she does in a style of writing I love the most. Epic, large scale and all encompassing.

Elizabeth is hard to write fiction about I think, but that doesn't stop people from trying. As a subject for a bio epic she's perfect-the woman was both the luckiest and unluckiest woman in the world in her lifetime and wrote all other powers in Europe to their knees. Not to mention the many rumors in her life. What happened with Admiral Seymour? Did Robert Dudley marry his wife Amy so he could marry Elizabeth? Did she and Dudley ever consummate their love? And what was the deal with Essex?

Read it and find out. Five stars to a great novel. The best, most realistic (as apposed to romanticized) version of her life I have ever read. In fact, one of the better books I have ever read.

The Light Bearer by Donna Gillespie

The old Roman Empire was a kind of nasty place to be if you weren't Roman. But for Auriane, a daughter of the Germanic tribes, it's become a hell on earth. All Auriane really wanted in life was to be like her lovely mother and have a good home. But being born to the warlike Chatti tribe as the daughter of the tribes' leader insures her life will different than she planned. From her first day on earth when a powerful seer/witch woman predicts she will cause the death of her father-the greatest sin a person can commit, Auriane is different. Over her short teenage years she becomes a daughter of the earth, a warrior women sworn to protect her people, and never know the touch of a man.

Yet all along a young man in Rome, Marcus Julianus, gutter rat who turned out to be the lost son of a Senator has been wearing a bag of dirt around his neck, a bag given to his father by a wise woman of the Chatti tribes, a bag that there is only one other like...around Auriane's neck.

Destiny collides in the fierce arena of the Roman imperial court and the terrile but lovely woods and bogs of Auriane's home. Auriane must fight for her life against the might of Rome and Marcus Julianus must fight for his own in the corrupt Emperors court...can these two people prevail?

This is a wonderful book. It's full of life, and the descriptions are so vivid I found myself wondering that I was reading a book, not falling back in time. The characters are all very real people (even the larger than life Auriane is insecure about her body) and the plot line is so vivid and realistic it's hard to stay still while reading. You will be running around, book in hand, screaming for the good guys and cursing the bad. This is probably the best book I ever read, bar none. And there is not one boring sentence in the whole book. Its chopped full of action, romance and adventure, and it's impossible to believe this is a first novel. I plan on buying another copy soon so I'll have one for mine falls apart. I'm sure I will read this book every year of my life.

I recommend this book to any one who loves history, drama, romance, or action. It has something for everyone, and I just received an email from the author saying the sequel is done (!!!) and it will be published in November of this year. Lady of light here we come...I'm preordering.

Five stars

The Love Knot by Elizabeth Chadwick

I wouldn't say that "The Love Knot" is the best of Elizabeth Chadwick's books that I've read (that will always be "Daughter's of the Grail") but it is second best, and thus, being written by Elizabeth Chadwick, it is very good indeed.

This takes place during the English Civil war between King Stephen and Empress Matilda (with her son Henry Plantagenet) and follows supporters of Matilda's cause over a period of about 14 years. Oliver is a man just home from the Crusades, where he made a pilgrimage in honor of his young wife who died in childbirth. Once home he finds that King Stephen has stolen his family lands, and signs on with the Empress Matilda so he can get them back. On a journey to Bristol to get orders he comes across a burned down country-house where he grew up, with one almost dead woman he grew up with, her young son, and his nurse. The nurses' name is Catrin.

Catrin and the dead woman's son (who happens to be the bastard son of the old king) Richard, are taken by Oliver to Bristol. Naturally, we have a love connection between Oliver and Catrin, both of whom are raw and damaged by the deaths of their spouses. Catrin also starts to learn the trade of a midwife, and thus we are taught a great deal about childbirth and healing in the middle ages (it wasn't pretty.) Reading this part of the book will make you glad that you we born in the 20th (or 21st) century and have access to modern medical care and good birth control!

Then something happens in Catrin's life which changes everything, allegiances, love and both her and Oliver's lives. But still they are bound by the love knot that Ethyl, the midwife who raised Oliver and taught Catrin, made for them.

As always, if it's by Elizabeth Chadwick you are guaranteed a good read. This is one of her more romantic and less biographical novels, comparable best probably to "The Marsh King's Daughter." If you like romance, medical history, action adventure and good twisted plot you'll like this book. I do agree at time the characters are a little stereotypical, but it's not enough to detract from the overall novel.

Five stars.

 

 


M


 

The Memoirs of Helen of Troy by Amanda Elyot

I don't think that Helen of troy is a good choice for a narrator in a book about her life. You may ask why, which is reasonable sincere this is a book about Helen of troy and who else should narrate? The answer is anyone. Helen is supposed to be "the face that launched a thousand ships" and in this book the first person view point we get from her just comes off as annoying and seriously conceited (at one point she likens her body to the tool of a master craftsman, but alas, she doesn't know how to use it in "love".) You get no sense of beauty hearing about the beauty from the possessor of it.

I don't know a lot about the Helen of troy story. This book tells it from the beginning. It does seem odd to me though that the whole saga of troy can be fit into three hundred and eight pages, much less the whole story of Helens life.

This book is a little bit boring to be honest. Helen is annoying, the action isn't described to its fullest potential and the love between Paris and Helen is never explained in any romantic way. And that, I think, is the biggest failure of this book. The love between Helen and Paris is supposed to be so monumental that thousands died to protect it-or at least thought that was what they were dying for. Paris and Helen are both so one dimensional in this that it just feels like a crush on Helens part (actually, all of her "loves" are either based on fantasy or lust. In fact, her whole life seems to be based on lust) and plain stupidity and fantasy on Paris's part. In fact, Paris is just stupid and not very appealing in this book. But then, neither is Helen.

So, this book gets three stars from me. Helen is annoying and unconvincing in everything she does, the people's relationships to the gods are explained in odd ways considering what an effect they had on the lives of mortals. If Zeus and pals were all made up by men to debase the great goddess (which could be true) how could Zeus have fathered Helen? Imaginary gods can't father anyone. Perhaps it's all some large and obscure metaphore for something else. Regardless, there is also no love in this book, supposedly telling one of the greatest love storys.

Margaret George's new book (the first in five years!), Helen of Troy, comes out this year. Wait for that instead.

 

 

Midnight is a Lonley PLace by Barbara Erskine

I feel I took a risk in reading this book. I had loved Barbara Erskine up until reading On the Edge of Darkness, which was very disappointing. But this book was a pleasant surprise.

After breaking up with her boyfriends Kate needs an inexpensive place to stay and write her new book on the poet Byron. So she rents a small cottage in northern England from a family who needs the money because the father (Roger) is dying of cancer. The elder son of the family, Greg, is pissed about the renting of the cottage-where he previously lived and painted. The daughter, Allison, has recently discovered a roman burial site on the beach that is about to be washed away by the tide that she thinks she'll excavate. But then creepy things start to happen.

This book is much more action packed than past books of Erskine's. The middle two hundred pages are non stop creepy action, and quite enjoyable. The ending however, was not so hot. It was very abrupt and kind of a let down from all that led up to it.

So this book rates a solid 3.5 stars. I wouldn't advise reading it for your first Erskine book, but if you enjoyed her other books you'll like this one.

 

 

Morgan's Run by Colleen McCullough

I was very bored while reading the first hundred pages of this book. Then, I was somewhat bored reading until Richard Morgan gets arrested. After that I was interested, but not fascinated. Once the ships headed for Australia though, I was hooked.

This book is about Colleen McCullough's real life great great, grandfather, Richard Morgan, who was arrested in England under false charges so he couldn't testify against a powerful man who he had caught avoiding taxes. From his place in prison, which is overcrowded thanks to the revolutionary war in America which caused a halt on sending convicts out of the British Isles, Morgan is placed on a prison hulk in the Thames. This is a grand experiment, to see if old slaving boats can work well as prisons without taking up land space. From there, Morgan, along with several other healthy convict buddies, are loaded into a somewhat better ship, and sailed off to the newly discovered Australia, known then as New South Wales. In this way, England solved its prison problem, and colonized a new continent ahead of the Dutch.

I'm sure a lot of the book is family legend about Richard Morgan's real life deeds, but I don't care. This book is a fascinating, brutal slice of real history and an amazing look at a man who will do whatever it takes to survive. Even if Richard Morgan tends to be a little cardboard like, his story and friends who are full of color make up for it. This book turned me on to a whole new area in history, and I'm extremely disappointed there are no other such books about the colonization of Australia.

If you're thinking about reading this, do. It's slow going to the start, but more than worth it in the end. I know it's a book I'll read year after year.

Five stars all the way.


 

 

My Enemy the Queen by Victoria Holt

I have to say, it's kind of sad that history has all but forgotten Lettice Knollys. She was, according to this book, one of the most vibrant and influential people of the day. But she also made a terrible enemy of her queen, perhaps explaining why more people don't know about her.

Everyone who knows something about Queen Elizabeth I knows that she loved a man named Robert Dudley, a man she gave great honors to and had known all her life. Some historians even believe that he killed her wife so he could marry the queen, and that they may have had a son together. But Elizabeth remained unmarried all her days (and supposedly a virgin) while Dudley had two wives in his life.

The second was Lettice. She was the Queen's cousin and possibly her niece as her mother was popularly believed to be Henry VIII's daughter through Mary Boleyn. She came to court when Elizabeth came to the crown and soon fell in love with Robert Dudley. Later they would become lovers and eventually marry. But always it was a relationship of three people, the Queen, Robert and Lettice. Later on, the Queen would give her son from her a previous marriage great honors, and eventually was forced to behead him when he led an uprising against the crown. In that relationship too was the Queen, Lettice's son the earl of Essex, and Lettice.

This book is her story. It's a little dry at times, being a supposed memoir Lettice writes before her death at the age of ninety six, but overall not bad. I do like to think of Robert Dudley as an entirely different person as described in this book, but hey, this was the authors vision and if she saw him as grabbing for power (which he was, true) and not truly loving Elizabeth for herself not just for the crown, that's her choice.

The only bad thing about this book is the most annoying way Lettice constantly says how beautiful she is and how she's so much prettier than the queen and all men love her and bla bla bla. It gets old fast. But hey, a vain women would probably write her life story like that.

Other than that, I just like to view Elizabeth and Dudley in a more romantic way then this book does. Possibly I'm deluding myself. But if you're like me, then read this, because its not a story I was familiar with and I bet most people aren't either, and then read the secret Diary of Anne Boleyn, for the very sweet scenes between Elizabeth and Dudley (part of the book takes place right after Elizabeth becomes Queen).


N


O


On The Edge of Darkness by Barbara Erskine

It grieves me to say this book is nothing special. The plot sounded amazing to me when I first read it on the website, but once I started reading it I discovered that it was poorly explained and executed.

Adam meets a young girl one day who he becomes friends with even though she lives in an odd gypsy village in the Scottish hills, while he is the son of a minister. They soon become lovers, but Adam moves on to be a doctor and when Brid, fearing for her life because her uncle the druid wants to kill her is rejected by Adam she swears to become the main focus in his life. Of course, it turns out Brid is really from the 6th century and has great powers that allow her to cross time.

The way Brid became accommodated to life in the 20th century is just stupid. No person from the 6th century who saw a car would be able to hold it together, much less eat chocolate without a huge sense of wonder.

Brid's situation as a person who can travel through time, change into a cat, leave her body at will, and do all sorts of other stuff is never portrayed as anything out of the ordinary, and as much as she does make Adam's life miserable, the actions people around Adam take to be safe from her are just plain silly. Also it's never clear if Brid really is in the 20th century, or just having an out of time out of body experience from the 6th century. Or both. Not much in this book makes sense, and the very end of the book is so out of place in the book it renders the whole ending stupid.

This is not one of Barbara Erskine's better books, and I recommend skipping this one. It has the feel of a draft written very early on that was never revised for anything except spelling. This book doesn't even seem to fit a category, be it historical fiction or thriller. If you want a real good historical book about time travel try the Outlander series by Diana Gabaldon, or Doomsday Book by Connie Willis.

I hate to say it, but this only gets two stars from me.

 


P


 

The Pillars of The Earth by Ken Follett

Ok, I bought this book purely because there's a recommendation on the front from Cosmo calling it "Epic" (what interested me was the word epic, not that Cosmo liked it.) But I was surprised, no I was thrilled, when only two pages into this book I realized it was one of the best books I'd ever read.

Ken Follett's The Pillars of the Earth is a true epic, spanning three generations of real people in the eleventh century in England. Centered on the building of a fictional cathedral in a fiction town this book is UN put down able. I really did lose sleep finishing it.

The book begins with a hanging, of a red haired, kind of ugly man. He sings before dying, in French, a language the Saxon villagers don't know. Then a pregnant girl with amazingly luminous eyes curses the three men, a monk, a priest and a noble man she believed responsible. The mystery of the hanged man is the underlining story of the book. His son, Jack, and young lover Ellen are two of the main characters.

I really can't describe this book very well, too much happens in it to summarize. So I'll just say this, the book has action, adventure and romance in spades. There is not one boring page in this book. I truly envy those who haven't read it yet.

My only gripes with the book are pretty small. Since learning more about the period it's kind of odd that Ken Follett didn't put anything in about the conflict between Normans and Saxons, and really, no woman in eleventh century Europe could wander the continent alone and be safe for a year. But hey, its fiction. Also the cathedral building terminology can be hard to understand, but having just visited some cathedrals in Europe I appreciate it more now.

If you just finished it and need something similar quickly, read The Light Bearer by Donna Gillespie for a similar writing style and packed story line, or check out my epic historical fiction listamania list.

And cheer up folks, Ken Follett is writing the sequel right now, and it should be published in '07.

Pope Joan by Donna Cross

There are many myths about a female Pope. There is a lot of evidence that there was one, and certainly the unhygienic conditions of the ninth century had room for one to disguise their gender for any length of time.

This is a novel. It's not a work of fact. Its not non-fiction. If you are Catholic there is no reason to be threatened by this book (I believe one review called it a work of satanic feminists). This is a collection of myths, which may or may not have some truth in them, which the author complied to come up with a story about a possible female pope. And it's wonderful.

This book is fantastically written. It's the story of Joan, the daughter of a priest. Raised by her Saxon mother, Joan questions blind faith and believes that use of logic will reveal the truth. Helped along by various men able to overlook her gender to her brain she is educated. But after the village she is staying in suffers a Saxon raid, she runs away and hides herself posing as a monk in an Abbey. Eventually she makes it to Rome and well...you can guess what happens from there.

This is a sold piece of historical fiction, and one of the better novels I've read. I recommend it to everyone who won't be horribly offended by its premise. If you are, well, lighten up. It's fiction. Five Stars.

The Prince of Dreams by Nancy Mckenzie


I don't know why, but I tend to get stuck on some stories and search for every book written about them. I obsess over Elizabeth I's relationship with Robert Dudley, faithfully search out tales about and of Sharazard, and lately, I want to know everything about Tristan and Isolde. That's why I picked this book.

This is the story of doomed young love. Tristan, a young knight whose birthright to the high throne of Britain was taken by his Uncle (with his help actually, he gave it up) is sent by the same Uncle (Mark) to fetch his bride from Wales. She is fifteen and will marry over forty Mark. Her name is Esselte.

Of course-you know the story. This is a pretty good re-telling of it but for a few details-the poisoned sword wound that Tristan received is just stupidly healed and treated. Tristan has a gay Uncle (nothing wrong with that) who lends nothing to the story but pops up now and then. Esselte's mother is absurd in her hatred of Esselte and Branwen's actions-she delivered the love potion to our lovers and then agrees to sleep with Mark secretly in Esselte's place-are confusing.

This book has also fallen to a classic mistake that comes with retelling this story. Mark of Cornwall is stupid, mean and downright evil at times. This is supposed to be a triangle of love, respect and duty between a devoted nephew, a wife doing her duty and a king. Instead Tristan constantly bemoans that he cannot save Esselte from the evil Mark. Clearly he could have at any time. His excuse of it taking down the British alliance is stupid-Mark's own actions in this book cause that.

In short the romance in this book is far better than in the other version I read recently, the White Raven by Diana L. Paxton, who focused solely on Branwen's tale. But it's still not very romantic. This book is also far better than Rosalind Miles series-which I'm sorry but was so boring I almost died.

I have to say that the recent movie did a far better job of making three likable characters for the triangle, and the dialog was perfect-not too sappy romantic stuff-but real words from people in a horribly desperate situation.

On its own this book gets 3.5 stars, but I'm still looking for a novel retelling of this story I can love. Who knows, maybe I'll just write it myself.

The Prince of Poison by Pamela A. Kaufman

The Prince of Poison is the last novel in the Alix of Wanthwaite trilogy. There was a huge publishing gap between the second and third books (over ten years I think) which can only be credited to what Pamela Kaufman says in her authors note-her husband died, and her son died of a brain tumor. If the author ever reads this review I would like to express my deepest sympathies on her loss.

I loved the first book of this trilogy, Sheild of Three Lions, and I was enthralled by the romance between Alix, a young, very vulgar and smart girl, and Enoch, a Scot in every way who takes in Alix as his brother (she was pretending to be a boy) and ends up going on crusade to protect her for the lascivious king Richard of the Lion Heart. And I was very angry in the second book, Banners of Gold, when Alix, told falsely that Enoch was dead, became King Richard's mistress because he needed an heir and was gay (sorry folks, but historical evidence confirms it) and she was the only woman he'd ever been attracted to. I was especially angry because at the end of novel Alix was pregnant for the second time with Richard's child (the first was miscarried and a girl), had just watched Richard die, had just been told Enoch was alive, and was being hunted down by the new king, John. It's a big cliffhanger I thought would never be resolved.

But now it has been. This novel picks up right where the last one left off. Alix manages to escape John-who wants to have sex with her and then kill her-and wanders around in the forest. Then she manages to find Bonel, her kind Jewish friend from Banners of Gold who's in love with her, and has her baby in a Jewish Commune. It's a boy, named Theo. Then she learns to cut jewels and a year later she and Theo head to England, Theo with Matilda de Braose (if you know the name you'll have a guess of what happens next) and Alix on a Viking ship.

But she's shipwrecked on England's shores-close to her home of Wanthwaite. She heads for home, determined to finds her husband Enoch, and when she gets to the castle she finds a wedding celebration. For Enoch. He thought she was dead.

Hurt but brave Alix chooses to ignore Enoch's marriage (she did after all, cheat on him) and head to London to pick up her son. But Enoch won't leave her, until she says she's going to get the crown jewels, which Richard left to her. So Enoch follows her-but Theo isn't in London anymore.

So begins the start of their seemingly continues trek across England, often with different people, but always Alix and Enoch-in their typical way ignoring the feelings between them and keeping a safe distance from each other. And always to try and contain the villainy of King John.

That's what this book is really about, the Magna Carta and the rights of the Barons of England.

This is a good book, not amazing, but very solid. My only complaints where that no sense of Time is in the novel, so its passage went unmarked and I had no idea how long something had been happening. I think the scope of the novel in real history was over ten years but I the story doesn't take nearly the time I think the real events took in history. I also, like many Americans, can not speak or read French or Latin, and would have appreciated an English translation for the conversations that took place in those languages. And I think the situation between Alix and Enoch was a little absurd toward the end of the book. You can't spend that much time with a person without at least figuring out if you hate them or love them or are uncaring towards them.

All in all, a semi-sold book and a nice ending to the trilogy. Four stars. I can't say I'll read this again, but I probably will check out Sheild of Three Lions again. I still think it makes a better novel as a stand-alone.

If you like this period in history check out Sharon Key Penman's "Here be Dragons" which is about John's daughter Joanna and the Magna Carta. Or "Lords of the White Castle" by Elizabeth Chadwick-about the life of one of John's Barons who forced the signing of the Magna Carta.

 


R


 

The Road to Avalon by Joan Wolf

The Road to Avalon is the story of King Arthur written as pure historical fiction with very elements of fantasy. This makes it quite a different story from the one that is normally told. There is no magic, no dragons, no quest for the Holy Grail and such things as are normally incorporated into the story.

Uther Pendragon and Igrane married and three months later had a son. Because Igrane was married to another man when the son was conceived (though it was Uther's child) they thought it best that the child not be Uther's heir. So he was sent away to be raised with peasants. Fast forward nine years and Igrane has had no other living children, so Uther sends his father in law, Merlin, to fetch young Arthur and raise him to be a king. Only when Merlin finds him he discovers the boy has endured years of abuse. He takes him home to his villa, Avalon, and raises him along side his eight year old daughter Morgan. But he never tells Arthur who he is.

Morgan and Arthur grow up together and are in love. But Arthur is reveled to be the next High King when he is 16 and he learns Morgan is his half-aunt and he can never marry her. They end their relationship. Arthur doesn't want to live without Morgan but she knows the country needs him and sends him away.

You can guess the rest. This is a lovely version of the classic Camelot tale and is very romantic and sweet. My only complaint is that Morgan doesn't have much of a personality-she's basically a reflection of Arthur, who is a lovely portrayal of a tortured soul who only exists because of love. And the choice she made about not marrying Arthur because they couldn't have children after her son Mordred was born seems stupid. I don't think that she did it purely so Mordred could have a happy childhood-she could have made him happy with her and Arthur. But other than that she's a great character. And it is nice how no one is really evil in this book or wholly unlikable-everyone is portrayed very fairly.

Anyway, good book. Four point five stars.

 


S


 

Sacajawea by Anna L. Waldo

Although I am very much into historical fiction I put off reading this book for a long time. In spite of the fact that I live in Oregon, and therefor have a fair grounding in the story of Lewis and Clark, this book just didn't look interesting. Also, its over 1400 pages long.

But eventually I broke down and bought the book. It got so many positive reviews I figured it would have to be good.

Wrong. This book is kind of like little house on the prairie-only not charming in the way children's books are. Basically, this is one boring book. The only real good point is that the main character is portrayed truly as a woman of her time and station, which although is hard to relate too, is historically accurate. But, really, woman, especially Indian women it would appear, didn't lead fascinating lives back then. Sacajawea did have her adventures, but the part about the Lewis and Clark expedition is over by page 600-which isn't even halfway through the book. After that she sort of just wanders around and does stuff-boring stuff- for about seventy years. This was a chore to read-I can't believe I actually finished it.

I mean, she is a great historical figure and all, but there's only so much you can say about Sacajawea.

Also at the beginning of every chapter there were these annoying long encyclopedia articles about what was going to happen in the chapter. Talk about killing the suspense (not that there was much to kill.)


Skip this book. It's too long and too boring. Maybe I'll use my copy as a doorstop or something. Three stars.

The Secret Diary of Anne Boleyn by Robin Maxwell

The thing that I will always love about this novel, which is the story of when the new Queen Elizabeth I is given her mothers diary which covers her meeting with Henry VIII through her death, is the extremely sweet romance between Elizabeth and Robert Dudley. While Anne's diary entries are interesting and moving, it is the scenes of Elizabeth's childhood with Robert and their subsequent blossoming of love that is the best written part of this book. Truly, the part when Elizabeth is remembering them at about age 9 is so sweet it might make a person cry. I can only imagine and hope for both involved their real life love was as sweet and gentle (though probably it was more power hungry on both their parts.)

Anne's entries range on a scale from being quite boring (the coronation process, the six years she strung Henry along while he tried to get rid of Catherine) to being fascinating and emotional. The entries around Elizabeth's birth are by far the best. So many historical fiction writers portray Anne as being cold and unloving towards her daughter. While it is true that Anne probably was horrified and terrified when she bore a girl and not a boy, I think she probably loved her. Other entries are funny and smart, showing Anne as the real vibrant woman she must have been.

This book isn't perfect, it has its boring moments, and some chapters are just so slow you might Fall asleep during them. Parts of the book, such as Elizabeth's vow at the end, make no sense if you read the next book in this series, "The Queen's Bastard." But for the portrayal of Anne as a real person, with not just a conniving personality, and the wonderful sweet expression of love between Elizabeth and Robert (where most authors simply portray Robert as grasping for power) I can happily rate this book a solid four stars. Having read all but one of this authors books I can tell you her writing becomes less stiff, and she blossoms as a historical fiction author-with a generous dab, always, of romance. Four stars.

If you want the back story on Elizabeth and Robert check out "Virgin: Prelude to the Throne" also by Robin Maxwell.

This Website Built and Hosted for Free at Bravenet.com

Report Content · · Web Hosting · Blog · Guestbooks · Message Forums · Mailing Lists
Easiest Website Builder ever! · Build your own toolbar · Free Talking Character · Email Marketing
powered by a free webtools company bravenet.com